Wedding Planner Brother Lost Thousands Planning Sister’s Wedding, Now She’s Calling Him Cheap

by

Chapter 3

THEME:
FONT SIZE: 18px

[Reddit User] − NTA in any way, shape, or form. Your time is valuable, and you sound like you have put a lot of effort into helping her with her...

She has offered you nothing in return at all, actually, when a wedding planner would normally be very expensive.

I think that is a lovely gift to give someone, and if she is going to flip out on you for not getting her a material item, then it shows...

What an ahole. Here is the gift you should give her: Add up all your time and what you would charge a normal client. Put it on an invoice.

Write "free of charge because I love you" next to the total charge. Buy a lovely wedding card and insert the invoice into the card.

Give it to her. Then she will see exactly what you got her for her wedding, which I expect will be a damn sight more than anyone else got her.

This has now made me angry, and I am going to angrily boil the kettle and make tea as a proper English person would in this situation.

IllustriousShake6072 − NTA. Loss of income IS an expense. She sounds like an entitled brat.

jrm1102 − NTA, your sister has some nerve.

diminishingpatience − NTA. She said it didn’t matter when I brought up that my connections have literally saved her thousands when you add them up.

Get her to pay you in full, then buy her something out of that money. Spend the rest on yourself.

This cluster suggested OP step back entirely, hand over unfinished tasks, and let the sister experience firsthand what happens when free expertise disappears.

blueboatsky − 'No problem, sister. In order to buy you a gift, I need to refocus my time on paying clients, so I will create

a list for you of everything that still needs to be done and let you take over from here. Enjoy!' NTA.

190PairsOfPanties − NTA. I'd back out now and leave her to deal with it all herself, and not get her a gift after this nonsense.

Dangerous-Emu-7924 − NTA. Tell her if she doesn’t think it’s a gift, you’re happy enough to cancel everything you’ve organized and get her gift.

Or tally up how much you’d be getting paid if she weren’t your sister and ask her for that money. Then give her a gift.

But honestly, who are these people who are so entitled that they ask for a gift?!

Taking a strategic angle, this commenter advised looping in a calmer third party.

JacobFire − NTA. And the cheek of her to get family involved in your argument!

I suggest you draw up a list of income and things that have cost you while doing her planning, and show your family.

Don’t bother showing this list to her; she will only get more riled up.

Instead, show this list to a more level-headed family member who can see from your point of view and let this family member or members advocate for you.

Sometimes it takes a 3rd person to make her see the light.

This lone voice agreed OP was right but suggested emotional detachment.

TheObvi0us13 − NTA. It was clear that this was your wedding gift; she's literally being greedy.

It's not worth falling out over, so I'd just buy the couple a $12 bottle of wine or something and be done with it.

This one hits a nerve because it blurs love, labor, and entitlement. The Redditor gave his sister professional-level work, real money savings, and weeks of unpaid time, only to be told it “doesn’t count” unless it came wrapped in a box.

So where’s the line between generosity and being taken for granted? Is refusing a registry item selfish, or is demanding one after all that help the real problem? What would you do here? Drop your verdict below.

← PREV | NEXT →
Table of Contents
Wedding Planner Brother Lost Thousands Planning Sister’s Wedding, Now She’s Calling Him Cheap
TABLE OF CONTENTS 3
01 Chapter 1 02 Chapter 2 03 Chapter 3

Related posts

In-Laws Say “Family Comes First”, This Couple Says Parenthood Isn’t For Them Woman Refuses To Let Her Stepdaughter Back In After Animal Cruelty, But Her Family Thinks She Went Too Far Country Neighbors Dismissed A Dead Dog, Then Got A Front-Row Seat To Revenge Dinner With A Friend Turns Into A Fight Over Wine Glasses And “Glazed” Eyes SIL’s Insensitive Comments About DIL’s Right To The House Spark A Major Family Conflict After Her Sister Refused To Help In An Emergency, She Calls Her Selfish And Cancels The Engagement Dinner She’s Stockpiling Plastic Straws For Her Disability, But Her Cousin Accuses Her Of Destroying The Planet Woman Leaves Her Former Friend And Her Kid On The Side Of The Road After The Child Endangers Her While Driving Future MIL Offers To Pay For Wedding Brunch, Then Refuses To Respect The Couple’s Diet Woman Decides To Report Her Friend To Management After Her ‘Harmless Jokes’ Start Messing With Her Job She Refuses To Let Her Daughter-In-Law Birth In The Living Room, And Her Son Is Asking For An Apology New Dad Considers Giving Custody To Grandparents, Internet Calls Him Heartless Boy Refuses To Get Involved With His Dad’s New Baby And Tells His Dad’s Girlfriend It Won’t Change Neighbor Blames Her Dog For Her Newborn’s Lack Of Sleep, But She Doesn’t Think It’s Her Problem She Called His Hairline ‘Receding’ And His Truck ‘A Piece Of Sh*t’, He Told Her To Leave Woman Tried To Be Considerate Of A Horse Rider, But After Getting Yelled At, She Responds Sharply Daughter Planned To Have Stepfather Walk Her Down The Aisle, Then The Truth Came Out Woman Refuses To Apologize After Telling Her Daughter-In-Law To Stop Crying Over A Kid’s Insult Ex-Husband Tries To Get Back At Her After Their Divorce, But Her Brother Has A Hilarious Payback Pregnant Couple Sets Boundaries, Grandma Says Her Opinion Matters More Man Refuses To Remove His Memorial Tattoo For His Ex, And Now His Girlfriend Wants Him To Get Over It